{
  "id": "operator-hand-sign-20261020",
  "date": "2026-10-20",
  "authority": "運営者の明示指示",
  "unitId": "2026-10-06:陳情:16:全体",
  "title": "委員会傍聴中の議員によるハンドサインについて、議会としての検討及び見解の明確化を求める陳情書",
  "reason": "運営者の2026-10-20の指示により、ハンドサインに関する陳情は評価を確定できないため、この案件による減点を撤回して0点とする。本人公約の評価経由も含めて適用する。特定議員の違法・不正や陳情の妥当性を認定する訂正ではない。他の採決・公約評価・減点根拠は変更しない。",
  "changedRows": 21,
  "unaffectedRows": 15799,
  "previousVersion": "2.0-final-adjudication",
  "currentVersion": "2.0-final-adjudication+operator-hand-sign-20261020",
  "scoreChanges": [
    {
      "memberId": "member-aono-naoshi",
      "slug": "aono-naoshi",
      "name": "青野直",
      "beforeScore": 63,
      "afterScore": 64,
      "beforeDeduction": 37,
      "afterDeduction": 36,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 17,
      "afterRank": 16
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-abe-harumasa",
      "slug": "abe-harumasa",
      "name": "阿部治正",
      "beforeScore": 87,
      "afterScore": 87,
      "beforeDeduction": 13,
      "afterDeduction": 13,
      "delta": 0,
      "beforeRank": 5,
      "afterRank": 5
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-ishihara-shuji",
      "slug": "ishihara-shuji",
      "name": "石原修治",
      "beforeScore": 81,
      "afterScore": 81,
      "beforeDeduction": 19,
      "afterDeduction": 19,
      "delta": 0,
      "beforeRank": 7,
      "afterRank": 7
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-inui-eri",
      "slug": "inui-eri",
      "name": "乾えり",
      "beforeScore": 88,
      "afterScore": 88,
      "beforeDeduction": 12,
      "afterDeduction": 12,
      "delta": 0,
      "beforeRank": 1,
      "afterRank": 1
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-ueda-kazuko",
      "slug": "ueda-kazuko",
      "name": "植田和子",
      "beforeScore": 88,
      "afterScore": 88,
      "beforeDeduction": 12,
      "afterDeduction": 12,
      "delta": 0,
      "beforeRank": 1,
      "afterRank": 1
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-uta-sakurako",
      "slug": "uta-sakurako",
      "name": "うた桜子",
      "beforeScore": 75,
      "afterScore": 76,
      "beforeDeduction": 25,
      "afterDeduction": 24,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 11,
      "afterRank": 11
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-ebihara-koichi",
      "slug": "ebihara-koichi",
      "name": "海老原功一",
      "beforeScore": 60,
      "afterScore": 61,
      "beforeDeduction": 40,
      "afterDeduction": 39,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 19,
      "afterRank": 19
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-oka-akihiko",
      "slug": "oka-akihiko",
      "name": "岡明彦",
      "beforeScore": 59,
      "afterScore": 60,
      "beforeDeduction": 41,
      "afterDeduction": 40,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 21,
      "afterRank": 21
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-ozawa-emiri",
      "slug": "ozawa-emiri",
      "name": "小沢えみり",
      "beforeScore": 64,
      "afterScore": 65,
      "beforeDeduction": 36,
      "afterDeduction": 35,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 14,
      "afterRank": 14
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-odagiri-takashi",
      "slug": "odagiri-takashi",
      "name": "おだぎりたかし",
      "beforeScore": 88,
      "afterScore": 88,
      "beforeDeduction": 12,
      "afterDeduction": 12,
      "delta": 0,
      "beforeRank": 1,
      "afterRank": 1
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-kasahara-hisae",
      "slug": "kasahara-hisae",
      "name": "笠原久恵",
      "beforeScore": 59,
      "afterScore": 60,
      "beforeDeduction": 41,
      "afterDeduction": 40,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 21,
      "afterRank": 21
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-kawamoto-hirotake",
      "slug": "kawamoto-hirotake",
      "name": "川本大岳",
      "beforeScore": 59,
      "afterScore": 60,
      "beforeDeduction": 41,
      "afterDeduction": 40,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 21,
      "afterRank": 21
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-kusuyama-eiko",
      "slug": "kusuyama-eiko",
      "name": "楠山栄子",
      "beforeScore": 83,
      "afterScore": 84,
      "beforeDeduction": 17,
      "afterDeduction": 16,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 6,
      "afterRank": 6
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-kuwahata-tomoko",
      "slug": "kuwahata-tomoko",
      "name": "桑畑伴子",
      "beforeScore": 59,
      "afterScore": 60,
      "beforeDeduction": 41,
      "afterDeduction": 40,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 21,
      "afterRank": 21
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-kondo-miho",
      "slug": "kondo-miho",
      "name": "近藤みほ",
      "beforeScore": 64,
      "afterScore": 64,
      "beforeDeduction": 36,
      "afterDeduction": 36,
      "delta": 0,
      "beforeRank": 14,
      "afterRank": 16
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-sakamaki-giichi",
      "slug": "sakamaki-giichi",
      "name": "坂巻儀一",
      "beforeScore": 78,
      "afterScore": 79,
      "beforeDeduction": 22,
      "afterDeduction": 21,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 9,
      "afterRank": 9
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-shimizu-hiroshi",
      "slug": "shimizu-hiroshi",
      "name": "清水大",
      "beforeScore": 61,
      "afterScore": 62,
      "beforeDeduction": 39,
      "afterDeduction": 38,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 18,
      "afterRank": 18
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-suzuki-yusuke",
      "slug": "suzuki-yusuke",
      "name": "鈴木ゆうすけ",
      "beforeScore": 60,
      "afterScore": 61,
      "beforeDeduction": 40,
      "afterDeduction": 39,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 19,
      "afterRank": 19
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-takahashi-akira",
      "slug": "takahashi-akira",
      "name": "高橋あきら",
      "beforeScore": 88,
      "afterScore": 88,
      "beforeDeduction": 12,
      "afterDeduction": 12,
      "delta": 0,
      "beforeRank": 1,
      "afterRank": 1
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-tobe-shigeru",
      "slug": "tobe-shigeru",
      "name": "戸辺滋",
      "beforeScore": 59,
      "afterScore": 60,
      "beforeDeduction": 41,
      "afterDeduction": 40,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 21,
      "afterRank": 21
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-nakagawa-hiroshi",
      "slug": "nakagawa-hiroshi",
      "name": "中川弘",
      "beforeScore": 57,
      "afterScore": 58,
      "beforeDeduction": 43,
      "afterDeduction": 42,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 28,
      "afterRank": 28
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-nakamura-akio",
      "slug": "nakamura-akio",
      "name": "中村彰男",
      "beforeScore": 72,
      "afterScore": 73,
      "beforeDeduction": 28,
      "afterDeduction": 27,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 13,
      "afterRank": 13
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-nishio-dan",
      "slug": "nishio-dan",
      "name": "西尾段",
      "beforeScore": 77,
      "afterScore": 78,
      "beforeDeduction": 23,
      "afterDeduction": 22,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 10,
      "afterRank": 10
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-nomura-makoto",
      "slug": "nomura-makoto",
      "name": "野村誠",
      "beforeScore": 59,
      "afterScore": 60,
      "beforeDeduction": 41,
      "afterDeduction": 40,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 21,
      "afterRank": 21
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-fujii-toshiyuki",
      "slug": "fujii-toshiyuki",
      "name": "藤井俊行",
      "beforeScore": 73,
      "afterScore": 74,
      "beforeDeduction": 27,
      "afterDeduction": 26,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 12,
      "afterRank": 12
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-morita-yoichi",
      "slug": "morita-yoichi",
      "name": "森田洋一",
      "beforeScore": 80,
      "afterScore": 81,
      "beforeDeduction": 20,
      "afterDeduction": 19,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 8,
      "afterRank": 7
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-yaguchi-terumi",
      "slug": "yaguchi-terumi",
      "name": "矢口輝美",
      "beforeScore": 59,
      "afterScore": 60,
      "beforeDeduction": 41,
      "afterDeduction": 40,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 21,
      "afterRank": 21
    },
    {
      "memberId": "member-watanabe-jinji",
      "slug": "watanabe-jinji",
      "name": "渡辺仁二",
      "beforeScore": 64,
      "afterScore": 65,
      "beforeDeduction": 36,
      "afterDeduction": 35,
      "delta": 1,
      "beforeRank": 14,
      "afterRank": 14
    }
  ]
}